Saturday, September 8, 2007

"Window Water" vs. "Talk to Me"

Stan Brackage's film, Window Water Baby Moving, is one of his most personal experimental documentaries that I have seen. It is a very detailed portrait of the birth of his first child. After watching this film, I have no more questions about childbirth except, "why does it have to be like this?" I think that the structure of this film was very interesting. After reading Chapter 5, I think that this film reflects the structure of a process film. He films the entire process of his first child being born. He begins with quick shots of his wife pregnant, waiting for the child to be born. When she begins having contractions, his shots stay in sequence as time passes by. When the baby is being born and everything becomes more intense, his shots become even quicker and he flashes back in time and repeats shots from the beginning of the film. Once the baby is born, the shots become a little longer and he shows their reaction and his wife feeding her newborn. I kind of liked the structure of the shots, I just didn't like what was in them. This film has no dialogue or music within it. I think that the silence of the film makes the images even more powerful. Once the baby is being born and everything becomes so intense, the images by themselves provoke a strong response from the audience and I think that sound could possibly take away some of that emotion. It is not one of my favorite films, but I can appreciate the artistic structure and creativity found within the film.

Talk to Me is one of the greatest documentaries that I have seen so far. I thought that the idea behind it was so interesting and unique. I think that is reflects the structure of a biographical film. It is a documentary about Mark Craig's life over 20 years. While panning across pictures of himself, family, and friends, he plays recorded messages from close friends and family members. The messages tell the story of what Craig was like and important events that have happened to him over 20 years. At first, I was hesitant to the idea, but the more I watched, the more enaged I became. When his father becomes sick, I felt so sad for Craig and his family. I didn't expect to become so interested in the story of Craig's life, but I was. I think that it was such a unique way to tell a story of someone's life. It keeps the audience interested and provokes emotional responses such as laughter and sadness.

1 comment:

silvashan said...

Excellent comments Kristen! Your thoughts on how brakhage paced the film are spot on. A true editor you. You clearly understood how the film flowed, and why. Fabulous reading! Keep it up!

And I dig Talk to Me too. I had this reaction in the first few minutes of..."oh, no, a cock rock ken burns film?" But quickly my snarkityness was gone and I just fell into the story and was cheering for people I felt like I knew.